Dear class,
It has been a pleasure teaching this class of wonderful minds so I thank you! Sadly, we are nearing
the end of the semester. This will be our last blog entry so make it count. Please answer the following
questions based on the material we have talked about in class and as well as the reading of the
Weimar Republic.
Questions:
1. What role do intellectuals play in a new government, such as the Weimar Republic?
2. Do they have a special obligation to be supportive and not overly critical of their new government?
3. When you learn about a new place and understand its political system for the first time, what was
the first thing that you noticed?
4. What are the stereotypes that fall upon the culture, military, and economic power within your
assigned region?
Summer I 2015
Friday, June 19, 2015
Tuesday, June 16, 2015
Weimar Republic
Top of Form
Bottom of Form
Weimar Germany 1919-1933 by Stephen Tonge
Weimar Germany was
the name given to the period of German history from 1919 until 1933. It got its
name from the fact that the constitution for the post war republic was drawn up
at the town of Weimar in South Eastern Germany. The town was chosen for the constituent
assembly because it was peaceful compared to revolution torn Berlin and as a
signal to the Allied peacemakers in Paris. The hope was that the Allies would
treat more leniently a new peaceful German Republic rather than the
militaristic empire that had led Germany into war.
The History of the
Republic can be divided into three main areas:
1. The
Years of Turmoil, 1919-1923
2. The
Stresemann Era, 1924-1929
3. The
Collapse of Weimar, 1930-1933
1. The Years of Turmoil, 1919-1923
The Republic
As the First World
War drew to a close, morale in the army and at home collapsed. A series of
defeats led to strikes throughout Germany. The Sailors at the Kiel naval base mutinied rather
than sail to for a final showdown with the British fleet. Soldiers, sailors and
workers formed councils or soviets with echoes of events in Communist Russia.
The Kaiser, William II abdicated and went into
exile in Holland. A republic was proclaimed with the SPD leader Frederich Ebert as Chancellor (Prime
Minster). The first act of the new government was to sign the armistice with
the Allies. Many including Adolf
Hitler saw this as an act of treason and the men who agreed to
surrender became known as the “November
Criminals.”
The new republic
faced a host of problems. These included:
Over two and half
million Germans had died in the war and four million were wounded.
The army and many
other Nationalist groups in German society were unhappy that the Kaiser had
been forced to abdicate. Some of these owed a very shaky allegiance to the new
republic. Many were completely hostile and viewed the government with contempt.
Economic problems
were serious, including rising prices, unemployment and a continued Allied
blockade.
Germany faced the
prospect of a harsh treaty that was being negotiated in Paris.
The Spartacus Revolt
Even before the
constitution had been drawn up there was a serious challenge from the left.
Many hoped to see a Russian style revolution in Germany. The left wing
Spartacus movement led by Karl
Liebknechtand Rosa Luxemburg began
a revolt in Berlin in January 1919. They seized building throughout the city.
The government fled the city.
Many feared the “red plague” and the defence
minister Gustav Noske used
the army and the Freikorps to
crush the revolt. The Freikorps was a volunteer militia made up of ex army men set up to defend the borders of
Germany. It was strongly anti-communist and took brutal steps to restore order
with summary executions becoming common place. Liebknecht and Luxemburg were
shot and the revolt was crushed. In Bavaria another Communist revolt was
defeated with Freikorps help in May. Political violence had marred the
foundation of the new state.
The New Constitution
Despite the Spartacus
revolt, the majority of Germans voted for parties in January 1919 that favoured
the new democratic republic. These
parties were the SPD, the liberal DDP and the Catholic Centre party. The
constituent assembly met at Weimar in February 1919 and Ebert was chosen as
president.
The new constitution
was very democratic. Germany was to be a Federal state with the states or
Lander retaining considerable control over their own affairs. The parliament
(Reichstag) was to be elected every four years with a system of proportional
representation that meant it was impossible for one party to get an overall
majority.
All people over the
age of twenty could vote. The Reichstag dealt with issues such as tax, trade,
defence and foreign affairs. As there were a large number of political parties,
there were many coalition governments. During the fourteen years of the Weimar Republic, there were twenty
separate coalitions. The longest government lasted two years. This
political chaos caused many to lose faith in the new democratic system.
The head of state was
to be the president who was elected every seven years. The president was the
commander of the armed forces and was designed to a largely figurehead
position. He did have the power to dissolve the Reichstag and to nominate the
Chancellor who was to enjoy the support of the Reichstag. Crucially under Article 48, the president
could declare a state of emergency and rule by decree. He could also veto
laws passed by the Reichstag that he did not like.
The Main Political Parties
The parties of the Republic
The SPD (Social Democrats) were a moderate socialist party and the largest of the
parties committed to the Republic. It was strongly anti-communist.
The Centre Party (Zentrum) was set up to defend Catholic interests in 1870. It
drew support from all classes. It was present in every Weimar coalition
government until 1933. The BVP was its Bavarian ally.
The DDP (German Democratic Party) was a middle class Liberal party. It lost support
rapidly after 1920. In 1919 it received 19% of the vote. By 1932 this was down
to 1%.
The DVP (German People’s Party) had reservations about the new Republic and at heart
they were Monarchists. They were supported by the middle-classes. The
outstanding political figure of the Weimar Republic, Gustav Stresemann, was the
leader of this party. Its highest point of support was in 1920 when it received
14% of the vote. By 1932 this was down to 2%.
The opposition of the left
The USPD (Independent Socialist
Party) had broken from
the SPD in 1917 because they did not support Germany’s continued participation
in WWI. It declined rapidly after 1920 with the rise of the Communist party.
The KPD (Communist Party) was formed from the Spartacus Union that had led a revolt against the Weimar
government in January 1919. It was very closely allied to Moscow and it refused
to co-operate, in any way, with the parties that supported Weimar. They were
especially hostile to the SPD. This refusal to support Democratic parties went
as far as allying with the Nazis (their sworn enemies) in Reichstag votes. This
was in order to further destabilize the Republic
The opposition of the right
The DNVP (German National People’s
Party) was set up in
1918. It was composed of supporters of the old Monarchy. It had strong rural
support especially in Protestant areas. They were Hitler’s coalition partners
when he came to power in 1933.
The NSDAP (National
Socialist German Worker’s Party) was founded in Munich in 1919. At first it favoured the
violent overthrow of the Weimar Republic. But after the failed Putsch of 1923
it adopted a legal approach to achieving power. The onset of the Great
Depression and the economic chaos of the 1930s greatly aided its rise. It came
to national prominence in 1930 when it won 18% of the vote and by 1932 it was
the largest party in the Reichstag.
The Treaty of Versailles
The news of the
treaty came as a complete shock to the new government and to the German people.
Virtually all sections of German opinion denounced the treaty. It was known as
the Diktat as Germany had
been forced to sign the treaty. On the day it was signed, Germany’s Protestant
churches declared a day of national mourning.
Germans were outraged
at the loss of her colonies and her territory and population to France, Belgium
and Poland. She also resented the limitations placed on the size of her army
and navy, the ban on an air force and tanks and the demilitarisation of the
Rhineland.
She felt that the
principle of self-determination had
been ignored in the case of the Germans of Austria and the Sudetenland. She
believed that the War Guilt Clause and
the reparations payments were unjust. One effect of the Treaty was an immediate
lack of confidence in the politicians that had signed it. This was reflected in
the poor performance of the parties that supported the republic in the
elections of 1920.
The Kapp Putsch
Right wing
dissatisfaction with the new government was worsened when the government moved
to disband Freikorps units. A nationalist politician, Wofgang Kapp led a revolt in Berlin backed by the Freikorps
and the military commander of Berlin. The regular army refused to crush the
revolt and the government fled to Stuttgart. Its call for a general strike was
carried out by the trade unions in the city and the putsch collapsed. At the
same time a communist revolt was crushed in the Ruhr, the industrial heartland
of Germany, with over a thousand dead.
Right wing
assassinations were to plague the early years of the new republic with leading
politicians such as Matthias
Erzberger and Walther
Rathenau assassinated. Many of the murderers were treated with great
leniency by the courts but the murders did have the effect of strengthening
support for the institutions of the republic.
The French occupation of the Ruhr
In 1921 the Allied
Reparations Commission presented the government with a bill for reparations
of £6.6 Billion. The Germans
could not pay the amount owed and over the Christmas and New Year, 1922-3, they
defaulted on their payments.
Seventy thousand French and Belgian troops occupied the Ruhr. They intended to use the produce of Germany’s industrial heartland as payment in kind for reparations. The German government began a policy of passive resistance and called a general strike. Some began a low level terrorist campaign. The French reacted brutally with aggressive house searches, hostage taking and shooting over a hundred Germans.
Seventy thousand French and Belgian troops occupied the Ruhr. They intended to use the produce of Germany’s industrial heartland as payment in kind for reparations. The German government began a policy of passive resistance and called a general strike. Some began a low level terrorist campaign. The French reacted brutally with aggressive house searches, hostage taking and shooting over a hundred Germans.
The economic effects
of the occupation were catastrophic. The loss of production in the Ruhr caused
a fall in production elsewhere and unemployment rose from 2% to 23%.Prices rose
out of control as tax revenues collapsed and the government financed its
activities through the printing of money. By November prices were a billion
times their pre-war levels.
The hyper inflation of this period can be seen from the following table:
The hyper inflation of this period can be seen from the following table:
Year
Month
Marks needed to buy
one US dollar
one US dollar
1919
April
12
December
47
1921
November
263
1922
July
493
August
1,000
October
3,000
December
7,000
1923
January
17,000
April
24,000
July
353,000
August
4,621,000
September
98,860,000
October
25,260,000,000
November
2,193,600,000,000
December
4,200,000,000,000
The rise in prices
hit the middle classes and those on fixed income very hard. Many who had saved
money found that their saving were worthless.
2. The Stresemann Era
During the dark days of 1923, Gustav Stresemann was appointed
chancellor and his policies would help to transform the fortunes of Weimar. He had been a strong supporter of Germany’s
involvement in World War I and advocated unrestricted submarine warfare as the
only means to defeat Britain.
At first, Stresemann
felt no loyalty to the new Weimar Republic and he opposed the Treaty of
Versailles. He set up his own party the German People’s Party (DVP). However his views developed and he
advocated a great coalition from the SPD to the DVP to consolidate democracy
against the extremes of left and right.
He became Chancellor
in August 1923. His government lasted a hundred days until November 1923 but he
remained as foreign minister in successive coalitions until his death in
October 1929. As Chancellor he took the crucial step of ceasing financial
support to the general strike in the Ruhr. He introduced a new and stable
currency (the Rentenmark) that
ended the hyper-inflation. He also crushed a communist revolt in Saxony and
faced down the threat from Hitler in Bavaria.
The Period of Prosperity
Over the next six
years, as foreign minister he sought to improve Germany’s international
position, cooperate with France and Britain in order to secure a revision of
some of the terms of the Treaty of Versailles. This policy became known
as fulfilment.
He achieved a large
measure of success. Under Anglo-American pressure France withdrew from the
Ruhr. Stresemann accepted the recommendations of the Dawes committee for a settlement of the reparations issue. A
moderate scale of payments was fixed rising from £50 million to £125 million
after 5 years and a 2-year moratorium (suspension) on reparation payments was
set. A loan of $800 million was raised for Germany, mainly in America. For the next 5 years American loans poured
into Germany which greatly improved the economic position.
The Locarno Pact
In 1925 he took the
initiative that led to the Locarno
Pact. Under this agreement Germany recognised her Western frontiers as
final and agreed to use peaceful means to ensure revision of her frontiers in
the east. Stresemann was a German nationalist and was not prepared to give up
what he saw as legitimate demands for the return of Danzig and the northern
half of the Polish Corridor.
In September 1926
Germany joined the League of Nations with a permanent seat on the Council in
recognition of her status as a great power.
As part of this
policy of co-operation, the first of the three Rhineland zones which had been
placed under Allied military occupation by the Treaty of Versailles were
evacuated in 1926. In 1927 the Inter-Allied
Control Commission to supervise German disarmament was withdrawn.
The Young Plan agreed in 1929 greatly
reduced German reparations to a figure of £2 billion and Repayments were to be
made over a period of 59 years. Stresemann also won complete allied evacuation
of the Rhineland by June 1930 (five years ahead of schedule).
It is hardly
surprising that when he died of a stroke in October 1929 at the early age of
fifty-one Stresemann’s reputation stood very high. He had also become a focus
for hopes of European peace. Hitler is reported to have remarked that in
Stresemann’s position “he could not have achieved more”.
Cultural Achievements in Weimar Germany
The Weimar Republic,
however weak its economy and its political system, was one of the most fertile
grounds for the modern arts and sciences in history. The republic also saw
greater sexual freedom and tolerance. Berlin, in particular, became a thriving
centre of many new art movements such as expressionism. Its status in the world
of the arts resembled the place of New York after 1945.
The Bauhaus school near Weimar,
moreover, revolutionized architecture, and the theatres in Berlin and Frankfurt
led the way internationally in the types of plays that were performed. Thomas and Heinrich Mann and Bertolt Brecht were world famous
writers. Philosophy also flourished.
Great film companies
made German cinema one of the most notable in the world (a position it never
again achieved). Fritz Lang’s
work was regarded as pioneering at the time.
Leading composers of
music taught and heard their works first performed in Weimar Germany. Cabaret became very popular and
the singer Marlene Dietrich’s
became world famous.
In the academic
world, the Weimar Republic "inherited" excellent universities and
science centres from the Wilhelmine period. Göttingen was the world's most famous centre for physics, and
German was the international language in physics and chemistry. Albert Einstein lived and taught
in Berlin.
Not everyone was
happy with the new cultural freedom in Weimar. To the right, Weimar Culture
confirmed the image of a hedonistic, amoral, and degenerate society. The fact
that many leading artists associated with the Communist Party (which was
fashionable in intellectual circles all over Europe) and the strong
representation of Jews in the new artistic movements increased this hostility.
When the Nazis came
to power most of the leading figures of Weimar culture had to emigrate. A mass
exodus of academics, physicists, film directors, and writers took place and
many went to the United States, which inherited Weimar culture. 20 Nobel prize
winners left and over 2000 people involved in the arts.
3. The Collapse of Weimar, 1930-1933
The Great Depression and Germany
Stresemann’s death
could not have come at a worse time for the young republic. The onset of the
Great Depression was to have dramatic effects on Germany
The German economy’s
recovery after the inflation of 1923 had been financed by loans from the United States. Many of these short term
loans had been used to finance capital projects such as road building. State
governments financed their activities with the help of these loans.
German interest rates
were high, and capital flowed in. Large firms borrowed money and depended
heavily on American loans. German banks took out American loans to invest in
German businesses. The German
economic recovery was based on shaky foundations.
The Wall Street Crash
The German economy
was in decline prior to the Wall Street Crash. There was no growth in German
industrial production in 1928-9 and unemployment rose to two and a half
million.
On the 24th October, “Black Thursday”, there was panic
selling on the New York Stock Exchange reacting to a business crisis in
America. Early the following week, “Black
Tuesday”, 29th of October, panic selling set in again. 16.4 million shares
were sold, a record not surpassed for forty years. Share prices went into
free-fall. Ten billion dollars was wiped off the value of share prices in one
day.
Effects on Germany
As a result American
demand for imports collapsed. American banks saw their losses mount and they
started calling in their short term loans with which so much of German economy
had been financing itself for the past five years.
Firms began to cut
back drastically. Industrial production fell quickly and by 1932 it was 40% of
its 1929 level. To make matters worse in 1931 a number of Austrian and German
banks went out of business. . Unemployment rose from 1.6 million in October
1929 to 6.12 million in February 1932. 33% percent of the workforce were now
unemployed.
By 1932 roughly one worker in three was registered as unemployed
with rates even higher in industrial areas of Germany. Matters were made worse by the fact that the drastic fall
in people’s income caused a collapse in tax revenues. Many soon were not in
receipt of unemployment benefits as state governments could not afford to pay
it.
It was in this economic chaos that the Nazis and Communists
thrived.
Crime and suicide
rates rose sharply and many lost hope. People deserted the democratic parties
in droves and turned to either the Communists or the Nazis. In the election of
1930, the Nazis made their electoral breakthrough winning 107 deputies while
the Communists won 77. Both parties were opposed to the democratic system and
used violence against their political opponents. Hitler’s Brownshirts clashed
frequently on the streets with their Communist enemies.
Bruning (1930-2)
The new chancellor,
the Centre politician Heinrich
Bruning, followed a policy of economic austerity where government spending
was cut in order to keep inflation under control and keep German exports
competitive. He increased taxes, reduced salaries and reduced unemployment
assistance.
While it was sound
economic thinking at the time, it only worsened the situation. The banking
collapse in 1931 made matters even worse. Bruning was so unpopular that when he
travelled by train he had to keep the blinds down as when people caught sight
of him, they threw rocks! He was nicknamed the “hunger chancellor”.
The end of Parliamentary democracy
Given the
unpopularity of Bruning’s policies, he found it very difficult to get a
majority in the Reichstag. He relied on Article 48 and the emergency powers of
the president to get laws passed. By 1932, parliament was being largely
ignored.
Some of the advisors
to the President including General
Kurt von Schleicher wanted to include the Nazis in government which
Bruning opposed. They wanted to bypass the Reichstag completely and bring in a
right wing authoritarian government.
Hindenburg lost
confidence in Bruning and they quarrelled about land reform. Bruning was
replaced as chancellor by the equally unpopular von Papen. His cabinet of barons had absolutely
no support and this was shown in the election of July 1932.
The result was a disaster for democracy in Weimar Germany. The
Nazis received 37% of the vote and 230 seats while their communist enemies got
89 seats. A majority of Germans had voted for non-democratic parties. Political
violence intensified with twelve people killed on the day of the polls.
The election of
November 1932 saw a decline in Nazi but they still remained the largest party
in the Reichstag. Communist support continued to rise and this worried many
industrialists. Von Papen was
replaced as chancellor by von Schleicher.
Von Papen immediately began to plot against von Schleicher and met Hitler. They agreed that Hitler would become the chancellor of a government made up mainly of von Papen’s supporters. Hindenburg who disliked Hitler, was persuaded to appoint him chancellor on the 30th of January. The Weimar Republic was dead!
Von Papen immediately began to plot against von Schleicher and met Hitler. They agreed that Hitler would become the chancellor of a government made up mainly of von Papen’s supporters. Hindenburg who disliked Hitler, was persuaded to appoint him chancellor on the 30th of January. The Weimar Republic was dead!
Political Parties in the Reichstag
May
1924
1924
Dec.
1924
1924
May
1928
1928
Sep.
1930
1930
July
1932
1932
Nov.
1932
1932
Mar.
1933
1933
Communist Party (KPD)
62
45
54
77
89
100
81
Social Democratic Party (SDP)
100
131
153
143
133
121
120
Catholic Centre Party
81
88
78
87
97
90
93
Nationalist Party (DNVP)
95
103
73
41
37
52
52
Nazi Party (NSDAP)
32
14
12
107
230
196
288
Other Parties (esp. DDP and DVP)
102
112
121
122
22
35
23
Main Weaknesses
Electoral system
too democratic. It was too easy for splinter parties to get elected and very
difficult to form stable governments. Parties could contest elections that did
not accept the democratic system. After 1930 many of the deputies in the
Reichstag were ether communist or Nazi and this made parliamentary government
became almost impossible.
There were twenty
separate coalition governments in the period and this gave the impression of
instability. Many believed that democracy was too weak to defend Germany
against the communist threat.
It was a republic
born out of defeat. Many Germans refused to accept its legitimacy especially
monarchists. They blamed it for accepting the hated treaty of Versailles.
Many within
important groups in society such as the army, big business, the civil service
and the judiciary wished to see a more authoritarian form of government. They
admired pre-war Germany and there was little respect for democratic
institutions.
The severe
economic problems that were faced reduced support especially the
hyper-inflation of 1923 and the Great Depression of the 1930s. (back)
Recommended reading:
Michael
Burleigh: The Third Reich: A New
History.
Richard Evans: The Coming of the Third Reich.
Richard Evans: The Coming of the Third Reich.
Weimar Germany
This site gives detail about Weimar Germany from an English
educational website.
This is an article from the online encyclopaedia about this
tragic period of German history.
This site is a good source of primary documents on most aspects
of German history including Weimar Germany.
Meet the web creator
These materials may be freely used for
non-commercial purposes in accordance with applicable statutory allowances and
distribution to students.
Re-publication in any form is subject to written permission.
Re-publication in any form is subject to written permission.
Last modified 5 January,
2011
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)